On Wed, 13 Apr 2005 21:59:35 -0400 (EDT)
William Donzelli <aw288 at osfn.org> wrote:
Being
certified as an appraiser is one thing; it doesn't make
you an expert with opinions about eBay and markets, does it?
Well, it sort of does, these days. The antiques and collectables
market and Ebay are connected so much that they will probably never
come apart. Even the big traditional auction houses have been changed
by Ebay.
If a person is a professional appraiser and chooses not to study or
include Ebay, that person is either a fool or ethically challenged (or
both).
My take? Ebay is eighty or ninety percent of the market.
William Donzelli
aw288 at
osfn.org
'Collectibles' is one of those icky words, though. People with an
antiquarian bent really are a totally seperate thing from
'collectables.' 'Collectable' carries with it the important issue of
scarcity. Many people 'collect' things specifically because they are
scarce, and because they are scarce, without much a real focus of any
sort on the history behind said items.
And there are the many thriving 'created to be collectible' markets,
like collector's plates, trading cards, etc. Which very much are 'fat'
that needs to be 'cut away' from the statistics when determining how
'big' eBay is in the market. Who involved with real antiques or
historical classic computer hardware, for that matter, cares primarily
about the scarcity of the item in question. That's a
speculators/hoarders market and driven by fads.
For an (offtopic) illustration, I happen to enjoy collecting old minor
copper coins from the British empire. I enjoy the history behind it.
You'd find that things like 17th century British farthings can be had
for a few dollars, because there isn't big 'competition' in the
collector's market for them. If I wanted to blow a whole lot of money
chasing after highly desirable 'rarities,' I could instead collect US
Silver Dollars, or US Large Cents. But it doesn't interest me, in fact
the 'compete to get the rare thing nobody else has' aspect turns me off
to it.
Remember, eBay all started because of Pez dispenser collecting. Regular
old kitch, a 'scarcity' driven market if there ever was one.