Restoration is very controversial. It is now coming
to be accepted that
some old works have been
"preserved" to death, and are actually in a state they evolved to in the
hundred to two hundred years
after their origin.
As a highway sign collector, I will add that highway signs with obvious
repainting also similarly seriously depress their collectability value.
While work done by the local DOT on the sign while it was up is generally
accepted, restoration post retirement is frowned upon, and extensive
repainting basically makes it a whole different sign anyway. Small touchups
may be acceptable for small scratches, and structural repairs are probably
kosher, but even those are arguable to really rabid fans.
One of the most well-preserved items in my collection is a (probable) late
1930's embossed US Highway 1 shield from Maine. This is all original paint,
which you can tell by the reflection. A similar shield that had extensive
restoration sold for about half the estimated value of mine, simply because
it was perceived to be less authentic (and I'd argue that it is indeed
less authentic).
--
------------------------------------ personal:
http://www.cameronkaiser.com/ --
Cameron Kaiser * Floodgap Systems *
www.floodgap.com * ckaiser at
floodgap.com
-- I am the Eye in the Sky. -- Alan Parsons -----------------------------------