On Fri, 25 Mar 2005 20:49:01 -0800 (PST), Vintage Computer Festival
<vcf at siconic.com> wrote:
First, the basics: I know my controller can handle FM
because I was able
to successfully copy all the files off an old 160K PC disk in my 1.2M
5.25" drive.
Are you sure about this? I thought the only difference between 160K
disks and 180K disks was 8 sectors per track vs 9 sectors per track.
I don't remember an FM/MFM difference (but I could easily be wrong).
Second, the 8" drive can successfully
format/read/write an 8" [disk]...
Still don't know if it can do FM however.
FM vs MFM is a controller issue, not a drive issue. The drive should
be fine, even if it weren't a Tandon 848 (which is a fine drive... I
have one in a Dataram Qbus chassis with a Dataram Qbus controller).
Unfortunately, I can't give you any specific help with your 8"-on-a-PC
problem... I have limited CP/M experience on 8"-equipped machines (I
have one, but haven't played with it)... mostly, I've used 5.25" disks
on Kaypros, and RX01s and RX02s... not what you are looking for.
Someone here mentioned a utility (IIRC) that should tell you for
certain if your floppy controller can do FM... I can't remember
exactly what that is, but I would expect _that_ to be the way to go.
Also, if you are doing this with an older motherboard (no onboard
floppy controller in particular), it might be easier to be sure
exactly what FDC you are using.
All I can suggest is to focus more on your choice of FDC and
application software and less on the floppy mechanism itself.
-ethan