--------------Original Message:
Date: Fri, 14 Sep 2007 21:09:17 +0100 (BST)
From: ard at p850ug1.demon.co.uk (Tony Duell)
Subject: Re: Wang 300 Calc
On 13/09/2007, Gordon JC Pearce <gordonjcp at gjcp.net> wrote:
It still doesn't excuse having a
physically-but-not-functionally
interchangeable connector for PS/2 mice and keyboards, though. That is
where USB has a big win.
Absolutely 100% concur. That was criminally stupid.
IIRC, the PS/2 mouse interface and PS/2 keyboard interface are very
similar. Both are TTL level interfaces with clock and data lines, both
have 4 signals on the connector (+5V, ground, clock, data), and the data
transfer protocol is much the same.
IIRC, the pin assignemts of the 2 interfaces is the same too, and it's
possible to make a device where you can plug the mouse and keyboard into
either connector, and detect what sort of device is plugged into a given
socket. The fact that most PCs didn't let you do that is not the fault of
the interface.
So why not use the same connector for the 2 interfaces?
-tony
-----------------Reply:
Why not indeed; old Compaq laptops have a single connector which will
accept either a mouse or an external keyboard (an external key_pad_ used
a submini earphone-type connector).
IBM allowed for both together; a mouse or external keypad connected directly
to the single connector while an external keyboard required a Y adapter
which routed the keyboard clock & data signals to the two unused pins.
And then there are the dual-mode mice which put RS-232 on the unused pins
and came with an adapter so they could be used either way...
Laptops were probably also a reason for reducing the size of the connector.
"Criminally stupid"? I suppose you'd also want incompatible connectors for
the right & left channels of your stereo? ;-)
Funny how on the one hand I read the sentiment here that people should be required
to pass a course in advanced computer science before being allowed to plug in a
computer, and then that they should be so simple to hook up that a retarded^H^H^H^H
mentally-challenged blind^H^H^H vision-impaired chimpanzee could do it;
just no pleasing some folks...
m