Far too many so-called designers today try to solve
problems by
throwing ever more transistor at them.
Yes, there most certainyl are times where
microprocessor, a DSP, A
microcotroller or an FPGA are appropraite. There are also times when
they most certainly are not. Far too few people spot the latter.
To toot my own horn a little in this respect, I recently had occasion
to build something that could switch power to a camera on for something
like ten seconds every two minutes (neither time interval needed to be
exact). This was because the things in the field would be
battery-powered and we wanted to save battery, and needed only
time-lapse photography anyway. (The purpose was to create a time-lapse
movie of a construction project.)
My first reaction was a 555 with a few external discretes to convert the
555's voltage-level output into a current switch. Built it, and it
worked. (I used bipolar transistors for the switching because that's
what I know; a FET would maybe have made more sense as the switch.)
Then someone mentioned doing it with an Arduino or something of that
ilk. But, on investigating, the uP solution would have drawn enough
power to significantly impair battery life as compared to my circuit.
Apparently my first reaction was the righter answer. :)
/~\ The ASCII Mouse
\ / Ribbon Campaign
X Against HTML mouse at
rodents-montreal.org
/ \ Email! 7D C8 61 52 5D E7 2D 39 4E F1 31 3E E8 B3 27 4B