On 25/09/2013 07:21, Mouse wrote:
But, yes, far too many of the smartphone generation
put the
engineering into the palmtop computer and treat the phone as, more
or less, an afterthought. And, of course, it shows.
Or it's a reasonable
engineering trade-off given how little the phone
functionality is expected to be used compared to everything else.
I'd agree
with you, except that they are sold as phones and it is
difficult to get a device that carries voice calls over the cellular
network that _isn't_ one of these phone-is-an-afterthought things.
This debate
is as hold as the hills. I see the same argument mentioned
everywhere, I hear it with "software bloat" and cars with computers but
, and I guess its the same in the US as in the UK. No one will admit to
buying a phone or a piece of software or a car or a TV because its
simple to use. No we buy it because its "feature rich". It been a while
but look at any comparison list in any "buyers" magazine and it will
contain grids of features and folks buy them because of the more
features. I remember when I was working supporting Microsoft Exchange to
PROFS/SNADS connectivity tools in the UK, around 1997. There was a tick
box next to Outlook saying you could use Word to compose your Exchange
e-mails. At the time Lotus Notes was the main competition and Gartner
was predicting a 50/50 split between Notes and Exchange. So as Notes
didn't have that "tick box" lotus came out with a "Feature" that
allowed
you to compose e-mails in Notes with Word.It was totally useless as you
could only read the mails with Word and I don't know any one that used
it, but it filled in the tick box! Madness....
I guess it goes back to this mis-quote :-
"You can fool most of the people some of the time... which is just long
enough to get elected...
But I would disagree with "it is difficult", it isn't!... expensive
perhaps but difficult no! In the UK simple mobiles are widely available.
I have a brand new Nokia C1-02 as provided by my employer. It sits in my
pocket for about a week till it beeps as its battery is getting low and
it wants feeding. Worse than a cat. Its revued here:-
http://reviews.cnet.co.uk/mobile-phones/nokia-c1-02-review-50003257/
but note it gets 3.5 out of 5, and Nokia can't make money out it and
have sold out to Microsoft. Why , well in the UK networks subsidise
most phones. Some one who buys a simple phone is usually some one who
isn't going to make many calls, or spend on data. They have it for
essential use. Some one who has say a Sony Experia T (my personal phone)
will probably buy extra services like data, so the network makes money,
the phone maker gets their phones subsidised by the networks and make
money, and we fall for it every time. I make more calls per month on the
Experia than I do in a year on the Nokia... By the way I don't think
there is any difference in call quality between either phone. The
Experia T is fine. As for VOIP much dep[ends on the "last leg". My son
lives in an apartment block in Salt Lake City and when he "Facetimes" my
wife, Ipad to Ipad (Skype for apple users btw) it works fine if he
leaves the apparment with shared broadband and goes to the local cofee
shop. Full Duplex voice seems fine given the path length and propogation
delays.. (analogue voice east pondia to west pondia never was good for
duplex because of the echo cancellation required)...
By the way if you want a real simple easy to use phone "Doro" are also
good and available in the US...
http://www.dorousa.us/
but again pricey, and in many ways the on-screen dialling on the Experia
is as easy to use as as the buttons on the Doro my dad had till he
passed away last Christmas...
Dave
G4UGM
It is thus
rather pleasing that somebody has finally seen sense and
integrated the cellular modem into my PDA. [...]
I think the only real complaint is that somebody in the marketing
department hadn't had enough Bolivian marching powder that morning,
and boringly called this remarkable device a "phone".
Well, that and, as
I mentioned above, stopped making real phones, or at
least far too close to that. I'm still using my Nokia 5190, and this
is a significant fraction of why. (It dates back to when they were
pretty much just phones - no camera, no Web browser, only trivial
games, no MP3 player, no appointment reminders - the clock in it
doesn't even keep track of the date.)
/~\ The ASCII Mouse
\ / Ribbon Campaign
X Against HTML mouse at
rodents-montreal.org
/ \ Email! 7D C8 61 52 5D E7 2D 39 4E F1 31 3E E8 B3 27 4B
--
Dave Wade G4UGM
Illegitimi Non Carborundum