On 3/19/13 10:55 PM, "Tom Sparks" <tom_a_sparks at yahoo.com.au> wrote:
----- Original Message -----
The M-Disc claims 1,000 year permanency.
http://www.mdisc.com/
Anyone have experience with these?
--Chuck
(wondering if we'll be able to find a 1,000 year old DVD player)
forget it there is no way you'll be able to play anything digital in a
1,000 years
because of Digital obsolescence[1] and add copyrights
the best example is the BBC Domesday Project[2]
[1]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_obsolescence
[2]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC_Domesday_Project
tom
I can still read books written a thousand years ago. Now THAT'S durable
information technology!
Media is only a fraction of the problem. There are perfectly good tapes
out there that have taken extraordinary effort to read (consider the Lunar
Orbiter image data) not because there's anything wrong with them, but
because we forgot about them and had to recreate systems. Storage is a
system that must be intelligible to... something.
I have some lovely multi-disk CDROM readers that don't work, because the
laser diodes were fragile. The media is still fine, but the readers
failed. Do these lifetime tests include evaluations of the hardware that
reads the media?
Truth be told, I can still read those CDROMs because other readers
recognize the standards - most of the time. I have drives that recognize
the 512B sector physical format, but they're becoming harder to find.
I have machines that interface with the SCSI standards of those
512-byte-sector readers, but those are beyond-EOL, too.
While I agree there are challenges, citing Wikipedia isn't exactly
scholarship. :-) There is a large community that is engaged in these
questions. The solutions won't be easy, but frankly the issues of
copyright are among the thorniest, and have nothing to do with the
technology of persistence. Bits we can manage, if we approach the
challenges correctly. -- Ian