Every time I'be both seem an emulator of a chassic machine (runinng on a
friend's machine, obvious) and also run the rela hardware myself, I feel
the emultor doens't come close to the experinece of actually running the
classic computer.
Before I came across Hercules, I tended to dismiss emulators in the same terms.
However, I find the experience of using Hercules or Simh remarkably close to
the experience of using the actual machine in question. Many users of certain
classic computers never saw or heard the actual machine they used and only
interacted with it through a terminal (or even a terminal emulator).
There are also other factors which prevent both emulators and real preserved
hardware from recreating the original experience. Factors such as not having a
real world workload to process and not having a realistic number of users
working the machine hard (as opposed to a few museum visitors at a time trying
to figure out valid commands).
(I don't know why I am adding to this thread which looks destined to go
on and on and achieve little except to demonstrate that different people
have different ideas on how things should be preserved and that most are
not going to change their minds.)
Regards,
Peter Coghlan.