Joachim,
On 4/17/2012 5:41 AM, Joachim Thiemann wrote:
I find the dislike of the Arduino by some people
in this forum a bit
silly, yet funny in a history-repeating way.
Silly isn't a strong enough word in my opinion.
I'm not exactly sure where the animosity comes from, because I think
that the arduino has done a great service to the community. At least in
terms of driving down prices on all boards of this nature. And it's not
just microcontrollers ---- FPGA boards, eval boards, accessories that
are easily driven from a microcontroller (like gps boards, etc).
Increased availability of parts.
There's more attention on the overall field, more people making
projects, more support and a larger advertising base for magazines. I
really think it goes on and on.
While they aren't likely to admit this, a lot of the old fogies here
specifically don't like the accessibility and ease of use. Projects that
used to require a specific set of hard-won and war-won battle
skills/medals to build and create now no longer do. So the barriers to
entry to have been removed, and they're pissed. The elite club they
worked hard to join with a large learning curve is now handing out free
memberships. Boo hoo.
It's similar to the no-code ham FCC license change(no longer requiring a
morse code test to obtain a license to transmit) years ago. The old
hams, while simultaneously complaining that their dying hobby was
growing smaller and smaller, said that this was the end of the world and
that the local repeaters would become the CB world of the 80's.
Guess what happened? Practically nothing, besides the fact that the
number of applications for a HAM license shot through the roof, and the
hobby was expanded and sustained through a surge of new hams. The
increased number of hams mean more ham equipment sales, more people to
support shareware that is out there, and so on.
The bottom line re:arduino is that anything that expands the community
by enabling people to build things that they want to build is a win-win
for me. Who cares if they don't want to solder? Who cares if they don't
want to understand digital logic? Who cares if they aren't seeking true
enlightenment? These people aren't even necessarily hobbyists -- they
are people who want to solve a problem. Why care about the way they go
about solving it?
Damn Whippersnappers.
Keith
P.S. One other thing, get your damn car going 10 miles under the speed
limit the hell out of the fast lane.
I don't drive. I just wonder if the new mini-boards really teach anything.
What is left to control? Toilets even are done. I just find it
difficult to see
how the uControlers can get past the Toy/Demo stage.
Ben.
PS. I think the idea of big racks, and blinking lights has a little to
with my mind set.