Having looked at the appropriate web pages, I somewhat
agree with you.
I
have serious reservations about the organisation of this event. I
hadn't
realised it was actually organised by Bletchley Park -- having
discovered
this, there is _no way_ I would waste my time attending. I hope this
desn't sound like sour grapes.
It appears that they have no clue about the sort of things that private
collectors get up to, and the sort of people who they really should be
catering for. It appears to be public show. Don't get me wrong, I am in
favour of us sharing our knowledge and interest with everyone, but
equally, having to explain for the 10th time in an many minutes that,
no,
this machine does not run Windows gets boring fast. I think back to the
very successful HPCC conference in 2007. Although members of the public
were welcome to atttend (I think you had to book in advance), it was a
very techncial event, If you hadn't a clue about A-level (high school)
mathematics, or simple electronics, or things like that you would not
have got anything out of it. And that's how I feel about a VCF-type
event. It should be a place for fellow enthuiasts to talk about and
demonstrate the machines we all love. If others are interested, fine.
But
it should be pitched at a level that assumes everyone will at least
know
what machine code is, what a flip-flop is, etc.
Some things struck me instantly. The default space for a private
collector is 1m*2m. That is nowehre near large enough. I could fill
that
area with a collection of _handheld_ computers, and that's a minor part
of my collection. I think just about any reasonable classic micro set
up
(keyboard, storage, monitor possibly a printer) with a sheet of text
(in
a large font) saying what it is and why it's interesting would occupy
more than that space. And as for a minicomputer, well...
There is no mention of power. Will people be able to power up their
private collections? If so, how much power per 'stand'. Note that <n>
13A
BS1363 sockets doesn't tell you anything. It may well be a total of 30A
or less for the entire room. Which is again nowhere near enough. And
what
about safety? There is a slight risk of electrical failure, metal cases
becoming live, etc./ What is going to be done about that? Or do the
organisers (as I suspect) regard classic computers as pieces of art,
not
to be powered up?
I found some curious statements for the flea market (or whatever you
want
to call it). 'No PCs' What is a PC? Do they really believe that the
IBM5150 is not a significant vintage machine?
And then 'No memory modules over 64K'. Is that bits, bytes, or words?
If
the first, I have some 96Kbit core emmeory modules in the PDP8/e on my
desk. Surely _that_ is a vintage computer. If, as I suspect, it means
'bytes' then how many of the follwoing machines are not vintage : HP87,
HP9000/200 series, HP Intergral, any Unibus or Qbus PDP11, any VAX,
Whitechapel MG1, PERQ (any model), etc, etc, etc. I believe memory PCBs
of > 64K byutes were available for all of those.
And then there is the question of security. I don;t think anyone could
be
ecpected to man their stand for the entire day without the odd break.
How
do you ensure that stuff doesn't go walkabout? It would also appear
that
if you are looking after your own collection you wouldn't be able ot go
to the talks or the flea market.
I have one regret. One of my dreams was to be present at a true classic
computer enthusiasts meeting. That is, a room where a number of us turn
up with our own machines, discus them, exchange tips and tricks, and so
on. A room with ample power. Of course the public should be admitted,
but
as I said earlier, it would remain a technical event. My regret is that
this is not going to happen now -- ever. The style of VCF-UK seems to
have been set.
But I truely wish that VCF-UK is a success.
-tony
I think you may be being a little too critical. I too raised an eyebrow at
the 64K memory thing, however I think is it not meant to be taken literally,
but just intended to mean that recent-ish PCs do not count. Also regarding
space, I quote (my emphasis) "*Typically* we will have 2m x 1m available for
those bringing systems, *although we will make more space for something
special*.". They also link to pictures of the US VCFs, indicating this is
what they want to replicate, and those *do* show working systems etc, so I
don't think it is fair to say they want art pieces and they don't want them
to work. I have to agree that there is no info on power available, so that
would be a concern. I would imagine that the security of your collection
would have to be your responsibility though, and I think that is as it
should be. I also can't see why you think this is a non-technical event, I
actually can't see anything that says it is either technical or
non-technical, I think people will make of it what they want, and I
certainly can't imagine anyone in my immediate family ever wanting to attend
such an event, so I am pretty sure most attendees will be enthusiasts.
I think time will tell whether this is a worthwhile event or not,
ultimately, I think if technical people want to attend then it will be a
technical event, if they stay away it won't be. As this is the first such in
the UK I think we should give it a chance and take the opportunity to
influence the shape of future events.
Regards
Rob