At 02:40 PM 2/4/06 -0800, you wrote:
I'm a little curious--what kind of success might
one have reading old (20+
years) HP tapes written on an HP9835? I was asked this recently and I
opined that based on what I'd heard, particularly from the HP calculator
group, that the chances of retrieving error-free data was not all that
good.
Was I accurate? Or are the 98xx tapes an exception?
Yes. No. They're ALL the same tapes and there are only two
different models of tapes drives (but both are very similar and have the
same drive wheel problem). Chances of reading original tapes at all are
less than 50-50 in my experience. First, fix the tape drive and test it
with a sacrifical tape. Once you KNOW it works*, format a couple of tapes
to store the files on (or better yet, hook up a disk drive and save them on
disks) then try to read your original tape. Read a file then immediately
save it. Repeat until you've saved all the files. Don't play around and try
to run the files, read other files or anything else. The chances that
you'll be able to read a file a second time are SLIM. I once experimented
with 13 or 14 HP tapes (ones that all had good drive bands in them). At
least four of them failed within 2 to 3 reads! A few lasted for about 10 or
12 reads (that's about enough to read all the files on a typical tape).
Only three lasted longer and only one lasted till the end of the first day
and it failed within 3 or 4 days. MANY HP tapes fail to read even once due
to bad drive bands, in fact I'd say most of them have that problem. You can
replace the drive belt with one from a newer tape but it's a PITA and I've
never had much luck with it. But I know others that say that they can
replace them and they work ok so I must be doing something wrong. BUT even
if you overcome the drive belt problem, the tape will almost cetainly shed
the magnetic media and you won't be able to read anything beyond that point
since it sees the media-less tapes as an End-Of-Tape hole. VP's webpage has
some excellant pictures of these problems at
<http://www.series80.org/Articles/capstan-repair.html>.
If anyone gets Gung-Ho and gets properly setup and wants to spend some
time recovering files I have a LOT of original HP tapes with HP software.
*Oh yeah, FYI the tape drives will work even if the capstan isn't exactly
the right size. That is it will write and read tapes formatted in it but it
won't be able to read original HP tapes or tapes written in another
machine. IIRC the capstan has to be +/- .008" for it to read properly. It's
been a long time since I worked on the HP-85 drives and I gave away all my
notes but >IIRC< the correct size for the capstan is 0.421" But I may be
completely wrong about that. I'm sure some of you have experimented with
repairing the drives and you realize that your heat shrink tubing, surgical
tubing or whatever you're using only comes in certain thicknesses so it's
difficult to get the capstan the exact size that you want. But here's a
little secret that I used to use. I would repair the capstan then measure
it's o.d. If it was too small then I'd take the tubing off and wrap the
capstan with thin cellopane tape. Cut the end so that it matches up with
the beginning of the tape and doesn't leave a lump. You can even cut the
beginning and end at an angle to minimize any lump. The tape that I used
was 0.001" thick so each layer was 0.002" thick (2 sides of the capstan
remember). I put on enough layers to exactly make up the difference between
the measured o.d. and the desired o.d. When I was rebuilding drives I kept
the final size to within +/- 0.001" and EVERY drive that I sent out worked
fine. The materials that we're working with aren't entirely consistant and
the results aren't always predictable so if the final o.d. was out by more
than .001" I tore everything off and started over. I also measured the
capstand from several different angles to be sure that it was round. If it
wasn't then I'd start over. Yeah, it was a long tedious process. That's
why I don't do it any more!
Joe
Cheers,
Chuck