Chuck Guzis wrote:
Am I imagining this or have others noticed the same
thing? Is this
another case of vinyl-vs-CD? I don't own an LCD TV and after this
experience am not tempted to get one.
Personally I find that LCDs give me a headache - I can use the one on this
Dell (*spit*!) laptop for a couple of hours, but for every desktop one I've
seen so far I can't get more than an hour out of it before I need a good, long
break. Maybe I've just never used the LCD equivalent of the high-end Sonys and
Iiyamas in the CRT world that I've always been used to?
I find the extra sharpness of an LCD to be a drawback except for very specific
kinds of work - for a lot of typical applications I just find everything too
crisp for comfortable use (which may be related to the headache issue above).
A *good* CRT I find to be about spot-on - sharp enough for everyday use but
not too sharp as to be annoying. Problem is, a lot of people have poor CRTs to
begin with, or don't do any adjustments over the years, all of which gives
them a bad name.
Oh, I also *like* the bulk of a CRT - for the bigger 19" and 21" screens,
there's a useful place on top of the display to park paperwork and things
(without blocking the vents, of course!). With an LCD, I'd still need it the
same distance from my chair, keyboard etc., but it's not really practical to
go stuffing things behind it. Despite the smaller volume, I actually lose
functional space.
Sadly a CRT won't win out on the power front. As for longevity - remains to be
seen. But with routine maintenance CRTs of ten years ago are still fine (and
of course we all have much older ones on our vintage gear). Plus I feel better
about reusing an existing product and keeping it out of landfill than I do
buying a new product (with all the manufacturing 'impact' involved).
I figure this is fair game for the list, as the G3 is
over 10 years
old and the HP monitor much older than that.
I certainly like the discussions around modern practices vs. old. (I keep
meaning to mention how I actually seem to have *less* useful real-estate in my
modern email client than I did in something running on a 80x25 display of 15
years ago :-) 'Progress' is a strange old thing...
cheers
Jules