On 10/15/2010 3:13 PM, Teo Zenios wrote:
----- Original Message ----- From: "Tony Duell" <ard at
p850ug1.demon.co.uk>
To: <cctalk at classiccmp.org>
Sent: Friday, October 15, 2010 4:02 PM
Subject: Re: Xerox Alto on ebay (not mine!)
My experience suggests that few museums would
dismantle a rare
machine to
produce documetnation and then fix it, whereas quite a few enthusiasts
would. Giving a very rarew machine to such an enthusiast is more likely
to produce inforamtion of benefit to the rest of the classic computing
community than would be produced if it was given to a museum.
-tony
I don't understand that logic. What you want is a collector that will
tinker with an item and modify it so he can print "hello world" on the
screen or printer a few times until he gets bored with it, blows it up
and cannot fix it, or dies and it gets trashed. A museum will collect
all the information about that rare device and keep it intact until
some later generation has the need or desire to see what made it tick.
The key difference is each time that rarity passes hands to another
collector things get lost and you have the possibility of it getting
destroyed, a decent museum will keep it from rotting so that
generations from now somebody can go back and learn from it (using
high tech science to see its layers without trashing it).
such museums are rare. for the most parts museums (and libraries)
operate as businesses and need customers and income. They will make or
rent exhibits that generate traffic. they rarely place a lot of
emphasis on the longevity of every little bit that could exist in their
sphere of influence.
the rare exceptions are such as the CHM and the Smithsonian. The
Smithsonian is picky about what it takes, but preserves artifacts quite
meticulously. The CHM has a lot of nice stuff, and from what I've seen
preserves what it accepts quite well.
I mentioned libraries, because they are at the bottom of the food chain
in my book. There are countless elaborate collections of books
dispursed to the far winds by clueless librarians. The rare exception
and model you would think would exist is a person like Al Kossow. He is
the rare archivist, who has the mission to save the software and
ephemera of computing, and actually knows what he is doing.
Most librarians, and such operations as almost any "Discovery Museum" or
such has the mission to bring in bodies and collect money.
the rare well finance serious collector probably is the best hope for
your rarities if you pass them on, as most of the museums frequently
already have what they need, and won't take say the complete apple
collection from the Newton to the latest Macintosh LC3.
Computers are not that old, let a few sit broken for a
thousand years
until a society has the desire to see how they did it back in the
stone ages. Hopefully by that time they can just replicate the broken
parts like in star trek and leave the rusting hulk as is for the next
1000 years.