Ocht ...
Ben >> "FPGA logic is too vendor specific to have portable code. who needs 3 ns
when 5 volt logic levels and simple packaging are more important in my mind when it comes
to vintage equipment."
Not if you write in VHDL / Verilog, the instantiated lumps (eg memory) will be different
but no more than the API between M$ and Borland C.
And if your interest is in vintage architecture rather than vintage hardware, 5V logic has
little relevance.
Ben >> " Can we still get the chips?"
The narrow answer is given the source VHDL/Verilog you don't need legacy silicon.
Taking DG Conway's PDP/4 as an example the XC4010 is probably no more obtanium than a
DS8641, and the Spartan family is only now going out of production.
Ben >> " I was thinking of the western digital chip set, that had the PDP 11 or
Pascal in microcode."
Acording to goo's AI the Intersil 6100 and Harris HD6120 both implemented a PDP-8 on a
chip; IIRC microcoded.
And IIRC the DEC T-11 chip was also microcoded with an 8 bit data path.
Martin
-----Original Message-----
From: ben via cctalk [mailto:cctalk@classiccmp.org]
Sent: 05 May 2025 01:28
To: cctalk(a)classiccmp.org
Cc: ben <bfranchuk(a)jetnet.ab.ca>
Subject: [cctalk] Re: Wang TTL BASIC
On 2025-05-04 3:13 p.m., Martin Bishop via cctalk wrote:
These days microcode works well in FPGAs, RAM access
times of 3 ns without pipelining, and as Xilinx BRAM comes in 1k Wd x 36b quanta eg 108
bits. BRAM and DSP resource permits implementation of pretty much any (array of) mills.
And the architecture can provide a plurality of parallel memories and address generators.
The sort of things which were conveiveable but probably not implementable in the bit slice
days.
FPGA logic is too vendor specific to have portable code. who needs 3 ns when 5 volt logic
levels and simple packaging are more important in my mind when it comes to vintage
equipment.
http://fpgaretrocomputing.org/pdp4x/
Can we still get the chips?
I was thinking of the western digital chip set, that had the PDP 11 or Pascal in
microcode. A version of BASIC could have been developed, had not Microsoft cornered the
basic market.
A final point is that most of the old mens techniques
remain current, Wilkes used microcode ~1950. What changes, is the price point at which
you can reduce to practice.
Martin
Here is $10.00 bribe to support RISC.
Ben.