Is The M9312 Boot Module Essential?

Fritz Mueller fritzm at fritzm.org
Sat Feb 19 15:40:20 CST 2022


> On Feb 19, 2022, at 10:51 AM, Noel Chiappa via cctalk <cctalk at classiccmp.org> wrote:
> The -11/34 (not the /34A) has something unusual for grant timeouts, but I
> forget the details. I'll look it up.

> On Feb 19, 2022, at 12:11 PM, Fritz Mueller <fritzm at fritzm.org> wrote:
> I just did an 11/34 restoration last year, so this is fresh in mind — I think you are thinking of the M9302, Noel: a far-side terminator card with integrated SACK turnaround?

A few additional details, in case it is helpful:

IIRC, the 11/34 doesn’t have SACK timeout implemented in the CPU cards (the /34A did add this, however.)  So without an M9302 on the far end of the bus, the CPU could hang in a situation with an unacknowledged grant (which I think would be somewhat rare, but possible).  I believe it is possible to boot an 11/34 at least as far as a ROM boot monitor with a non-SACK (M930 or such) terminator on the far side.

An 11/34 with a M9302 SACK terminator _will_ hang, though, with a broken grant chain — the floating grant will trigger the M9302 to continuously assert SACK locking the bus.  “Better” CPUs, which used SACK timeout instead of turn-around, were more robust this way.

Incidentally, I think the 11/34 was contemporaneous with, and usually found with, the slightly earlier M9301 ROM terminator on the near side, rather than the later M9312, though both should work fine.

    cheers,
        —FritzM.




More information about the cctech mailing list