At 10:22 PM 4/1/2025, Chuck Guzis via cctalk wrote:
Apparently, some think that within 10 years, AI will
replace doctors and
teachers:
It's one thing to say that AI methods have been shown to give better
diagnoses in some situations than the humans, it's quite another to
suggest we won't need doctors. In my neck of the woods, even doctors
have been greatly supplanted by physician assistants.
I'm as skeptical as they come, and I have plenty of criticisms of AI
as implemented today, but I've also been confounded to discover how
useful it can be when programming. It's often better than googling and
copy-and-pasting from Stackoverflow.
I've generally used Copilot as it comes with M365. In a recent Perl tool
that needed a few dozen regular expressions, it was very handy, providing
not only correct regexs but also snippets of the surrounding code.
In another task where I wanted to quickly generate a text-based
profile of a computer's specifications and components, it was very
helpful in writing a bunch of PowerShell. Did it hallucinate?
Perhaps once out of several dozen things I asked it, and in that
case, it was easy to see that the two clauses of the if-then were
the same.
I've heard similar puzzlement from a very experienced programmer
friend who told me about the way his IDE would now suggest code
to him while he was typing, and he thought the suggested code was
good and very similar if not identical to what he was about to write.
- John