[cctalk] Re: Good C to FPGA/PLA compiler

I only know VHDL but I had heard that Verilog is C-like, and yes, C offers an unusually large set of tools to shoot yourself in the foot with. So it wouldn't surprise me that Verilog does likewise, which certainly means that it would be the option to avoid. VHDL is very clearly based on Ada, which like Pascal and ALGOL takes data types seriously rather than only as suggestions the way C does. I've built some very large designs with VHDL, but not because I actually wrote that much code -- a lot is generated code produced from wire lists. But I did write all the models of all the 6000 modules, which does add up. Apart from vendor tools for producing bits for particular FPGAs, you can also find VHDL simulators that just simulate a model but don't deliver it to a particular chip. I use GHDL, which is part of the GCC toolset. Yes, a VHDL compiler, interesting. Among other things, it allows you to link bits in other languages, so I can take device models from the DtCyber emulator and attach them to a VHDL-modeled I/O channel. On FPGAs, it's worth checking what the story is for vendor tools. Some devices and vendors try to suck large sums of money out of you for them; Lattice is an example. Even for small devices (like the ispLSI2032 I used years ago) that expense adds up rapidly. I think they have become somewhat more reasonable now, offering free tools for the smaller devices. I know Xilinx does so, and "smaller" covers a surprising amount of capacity these days. I'm pretty sure a PDP-11 model would fit fine in one of those "free tool" devices, though a CDC 6600 probably won't. paul